[DRAFT] Artemis Proposal to Build Public Goods Data Dashboards for Celo Ecosystem and Community

Abstract

Artemis, a data provider trusted by top investors like Pantera, Dragonfly, Grayscale, VanEck, Coinfund, and Franklin Templeton, proposes to build open-source dashboards for the Celo ecosystem. These dashboards will highlight stablecoin and dapp activity, and showcase Celo’s recent growth. Our institutional-grade data aids major investors in key decisions, and these public goods will improve Celo’s transparency and visibility with institutional investors–allowing for potential future investments in the ecosystem.

We are seeking funding in cUSD or CELO to support the development and operation of two key tools for one year:

  • Application Activity Monitor: Track dapp usage over time on Celo and discover trending applications in the Celo ecosystem. Explore the Activity Monitor here.
  • Stablecoin Dashboard for the Celo Foundation + Celo Community: Provide comprehensive tracking and analysis of stablecoin activities on the Celo platform. Some dashboards for Celo Foundation will be private for now as requested by Celo Foundation.

Ultimately, these dashboards will also empower the Celo community with valuable insights and drive informed decision-making such as usage of various stables, efficacy of incentive programs.

About Artemis

  • Artemis is an institutional-grade data provider, specializing in serving respected investors in the crypto space, including Pantera, Dragonfly, Grayscale, VanEck, Coinfund, and Franklin Templeton.
  • We collaborate closely with top blockchains and developers such as Solana, Consensys, Near, and Avalanche to offer reliable data for wallet analysis, application usage analysis, grant efficacy analysis, and stablecoin tracking.
  • Our data is open source and all dashboards are built as public goods, freely accessible to everyone. You can explore our open-source data here.
  • Artemis builds closely with every ecosystem to ensure that the data we represent is fair, accurate, and transparent.

Deliverables

Application Activity Monitor (timeline: 1.5 months after proposal passes)

  • 2 weeks: Work with Celo foundation on tagging all relevant contracts
  • 2-3 weeks: [Backend engineering] Build data pipelines and materialize tables
  • 1 week: [Frontend engineering] Build and add dashboard to frontend
  • 1 week: QA data and beta test

Stablecoin Dashboards (timeline: 2 months after proposal passes)

  • 1 week: Work with Celo Foundation to identify all relevant stable addresses
  • 1-2 weeks: Design new dashboards
  • 2-3 weeks: [Backend engineering] Build data pipelines and materialize tables
  • 1 week: [Frontend engineering] Build and add dashboard to frontend
  • 1 week: QA data and beta test

Protocol Highlight (timeline: 1 week after proposal passes)

  • Regularly published insights and analyses of key protocols within the Celo ecosystem. Example: Protocol Highlight: Open Network (TON). These highlights will showcase promising projects and innovations, helping to raise awareness and attract attention to the Celo ecosystem.

Ongoing Maintenance and Support

  • Continuous updates to the dashboards to add new stablecoins and improve user experience.
  • Dedicated support to address any issues and ensure the tools meet the evolving needs of the Celo community.

Motivation

Application Activity Monitor

The Application Activity dashboard enables investors, protocol developers, and community members to monitor the usage of protocols and dapps on the Celo blockchain. For example, users can track the number of Daily Active Users (DAUs) for Valora on-chain. This provides critical insights into the functionality and engagement within the Celo ecosystem.

Additionally, this tool helps viewers understand the primary use cases of the chain. For instance Base is increasingly used for DeFi over the past year as you can see below:

Whereas something like Tron is primarily used for p2p transfers as shown below:

This understanding is crucial for any blockchain as it allows foundations and builders to align their efforts with the community’s long-term goals. For Celo, being a chain focused on real-world usage, it is essential to see RWAs (Real World Assets) and stablecoins proliferate the main use cases. Furthermore, this dashboard facilitates benchmarking Celo against other ecosystems.

Investors highly value the Activity Monitor as it provides a comprehensive view of the applications on the chain and their usage metrics. This is a critical component of a token investor’s due diligence process. Without this data, investors may lack the confidence to invest in a particular token, potentially hindering the ecosystem’s growth due to unclear usage patterns. For example, Franklin Templeton uses the Activity Monitor to evaluate the usage of Base and Friend.tech on Base.

The App Activity Monitor can be thought of as a more in-depth Dapp Radar specifically built for institutional investors and power users. Artemis will offer it for free on app.artemis.xyz as a public good for Celo and the crypto ecosystem.

Stablecoin Dashboard

Widespread adoption of stablecoins is crucial to Celo’s mission of prosperity for all, making it essential to track and analyze stablecoin performance both on Celo and benchmark against other ecosystems.

Given the critical role of stablecoins in Celo’s future, Artemis, in collaboration with Celo Foundation’s Michael Kwan and Kevin Tharayil, proposes three sub-projects as part of this initiative:

A. Ongoing Maintenance and Updates

Artemis will maintain and continually update the Celo stablecoin dashboard (Artemis Dashboard). This includes adding new currencies and enhancing user-friendliness to ensure it meets the needs of the community.

B. Aggregated TVL and Transaction Volume Tracking

We will provide a comprehensive view of the Total Value Locked (TVL) for each stablecoin across the top 30 Uniswap pools, including USDC, USDGLO, USDT, cEUR, cREAL, cUSD, and cKES. This will include tracking 1-day, 7-day, and 1-month % changes, along with export functionality for this data.

Additionally, we will track transaction and transfer volumes for each stable-stable pool involving supported stablecoins, providing similar percentage change metrics and export options. Examples of such pools include USDT/USDC with a 0.01% fee, USDT/cEUR with a 0.01% fee, and cUSD/USDC with a 0.01% fee. For an exhaustive list, refer to Uniswap Pools.

C. Stabila Campaign Efficacy Analysis

Artemis will analyze the success of Stabila campaigns by tracking daily rewards for pools with partners like Uniswap and some centralized exchanges.

The goal is to significantly increase stablecoin volumes and improve utilization by providing incentives. This involves measuring the return on investment (ROI) for campaigns, such as determining the impact of adding a $100 incentive to a pool on transaction volumes.

This analysis will include Merkle campaigns and wallet campaigns to gauge their effectiveness. While the exact specifications are still being finalized, Artemis commits to building the necessary dashboards and analysis, assuming it is not overly burdensome.

Specifications

Product Features (Application Activity Monitor)

The Application Activity Monitor enables anyone to see which Celo applications are driving usage. This tool is invaluable for investors conducting due diligence and screening new protocols for potential investment. Key features include:

  • Sector Analysis: This feature breaks down Celo’s blockchain usage by sector, allowing users to track over time the percentage of usage dedicated to P2P payments, DeFi, NFTs, and more. For example, similar sector analysis on Ethereum provides insights into the health and diversity of its ecosystem. Investors rely on this analysis to understand the robustness and breadth of a chain’s ecosystem before making investment decisions.
  • Gas Guzzlers: This feature tracks which dapps are generating the most fees on the chain. High fee generation is a strong indicator of a dapp gaining traction and demonstrates user willingness to pay for the application’s services. This metric is crucial for identifying high-demand applications within the ecosystem.
  • Trending Apps: The Application Activity Monitor also highlights dapps that have seen the most significant increases in DAUs, daily transactions, and gas usage. This helps users identify which applications are gaining popularity and traction within the ecosystem. Trending applications are excellent candidates for Celo’s Bloom initiative (bloom.celo.org), aiding Bloom organizers in identifying and supporting promising protocol teams.

Product Features (Stablecoin Dashboards)

Two stablecoin-related projects have been requested by the Celo Foundation to drive the success of Celo stablecoin adoption and to monitor the Stabila campaign (Stabila Proposal).

1) Exchange Pool Tracker

Overview: The Exchange Pool Tracker provides comprehensive tracking of stablecoin activities across various exchange pools. This tool is essential for understanding liquidity, transaction volumes, and overall market dynamics of Celo stablecoins.

Features:

  • Total Value Locked (TVL): Track the aggregated TVL for each stablecoin across all Uniswap pools, including USDC, USDGLO, USDT, cEUR, cREAL, cUSD, and cKES. This metric includes 1-day, 7-day, and 1-month percentage changes, providing insights into liquidity trends over time. The data can be exported for further analysis.
  • Transaction/Transfer Volume: Monitor transaction and transfer volumes for each stable-stable pool involving supported stablecoins. The tracker will display TVL, transaction/transfer volume amounts, and percentage changes over 1-day, 7-day, and 1-month periods. This data is also exportable, allowing for detailed analysis.

Example Pools:

  • USDT/USDC 0.01% fee pool
  • USDT/cEUR 0.01% fee pool
  • cUSD/USDC 0.01% fee pool
  • For an exhaustive list of pools, refer to Uniswap Pools.

2) Stabila Campaign Efficacy Analysis

Overview: The Stabila Campaign Efficacy Analysis tool will evaluate the success of the Stabila campaigns aimed at increasing stablecoin adoption on Celo. This involves tracking the impact of daily rewards, incentives, and other promotional activities.

Features:

  • Campaign Performance Metrics: Analyze how successful Stabila campaigns are by tracking daily rewards for pools partnered with Uniswap and centralized exchanges. The goal is to significantly boost stablecoin volumes and improve utilization.
  • Return on Investment (ROI) Tracking: Measure the ROI for campaigns by assessing the impact of incentives on transaction volumes. For instance, determine how much volume is generated by adding a $100 incentive to a pool.
  • Comprehensive Campaign Analysis: Include Merkle campaigns and wallet campaigns to gauge their effectiveness. Artemis commits to building the necessary dashboards and conducting thorough analysis to support these efforts, ensuring they are not overly burdensome.

3) Ongoing maintenance of Stablecoin Dashboard (https://app.artemis.xyz/stablecoins?chain=celo)

Overview: Continuous maintenance and updates are essential to keep the stablecoin dashboards relevant and user-friendly. This ensures that the Celo community and stakeholders have access to the most accurate and up-to-date information.

Features:

  • Regular Updates: Keep the stablecoin dashboards updated with new stablecoin additions and the latest data. This includes support for new currencies and ensuring all relevant metrics are accurately represented (such as adding cKES: [FINAL] Launch of a Kenyan Shilling Stablecoin).
  • User-Friendly Enhancements: Continuously improve the user interface and user experience based on feedback from the community. This ensures the dashboards are easy to navigate and provide the necessary insights at a glance.
  • Comprehensive Support: Provide ongoing support to ensure that the stablecoin dashboards meet the evolving needs of the Celo Foundation and the broader community. This includes working closely with key stakeholders, like Mento lead Marcus, to ensure the dashboards align with strategic objectives.
  • Wallet to wallet tracking for all stablecoin currencies on Celo:
    – Volume
    – Daily Transactions
    – Monthly Active Users (MAU)
    – Weekly Active Users (WAU)
    – Daily Active Users (DAU)

Why Artemis?

  • Free and Open Access: Artemis is the most suitable data provider, backed by an elite team of software engineers with extensive data engineering experience from Coinbase, Microsoft, and Google. Founded by Jon Ma and Anthony Yim, Artemis was created to democratize financial education and access, inspired by their experiences in traditional finance where high-quality investments were often exclusive. Artemis is committed to improving rationality, transparency, and accessibility of blockchain data, ensuring that all data will always be free to use and access at app.artemis.xyz.
  • Close Relationships with RWA and Stablecoin Builders: Artemis works closely with key leaders in the Real World Assets (RWA) and Stablecoin space, such as Castle Island Ventures, BlueChip.org, and Standard & Poor’s. These relationships enable Artemis to stay at the forefront of developments in the industry, ensuring that our data are in the hands of the key opinion leaders of the space.
  • Most Cited Institutional Data Provider in the Space:
  • Trusted by key Celo stakeholders already:

Funding Request

Artemis offers comprehensive solutions with the Application Activity Monitor and Stablecoin Dashboard, priced based on the equivalent cost of hiring 2-3 full-time employees (FTEs) per year to build and maintain similar data infrastructure as well as what other ecosystems are paying for Artemis’ services.

  • Application Activity Monitor: $150,000 per year
  • Stablecoin Dashboard: $124,000 per year

Our pricing model reflects the extensive expertise and ongoing support required to ensure these tools are continuously updated, reliable, and user-friendly.

Total Funding Request: $274,000 per year

Multisig Signers: Add wallet address here about who will be on the multisig that receives the funding

Conclusion

Integrating Artemis into the Celo ecosystem will significantly enhance transparency, usability, and adoption of Celo’s blockchain technology, especially towards liquid token investors and large financial institutions–the core customers of Artemis and potential investors of the Celo ecosystem. Many of these customers are not aware of all the new developments of Celo as they understand Celo as a climate focused chain. Artemis can help provide investors an up-to-date, unbiased and data-backed view on the latest developments of Celo including its transition to an Ethereum L2 so that Celo remains top-of-mind in the investor community.

By providing comprehensive data solutions such as the Application Activity Monitor and Stablecoin Dashboard, Artemis will also empower the Celo community with valuable insights and drive informed decision-making. This partnership aligns with Celo’s mission of financial inclusion and stability, supporting the ecosystem’s growth and long-term success.

5 Likes

Hi, @andromedae88, thanks for sharing such a detailed draft and the monitoring you already do for Celo!

Some Qs from my side:

  1. Will there be a process for the Celo ecosystem to request additional data points / views after the initial launch?

  2. Could you provide a breakdown of the pricing for each of the two dashboards between the initial two months (development) and the next ten months (maintenance)?

Hi @LuukDAO – those are excellent questions!

  1. Will there be a process for the Celo ecosystem to request additional data points / views after the initial launch?

Yes! As an Enterprise partner of Artemis, you have direct access to the leadership team and engineers via Telegram or Slack for any questions, updates, or maintenance requests. In addition, we guarantee a same-day response time for all communication.

  1. Could you provide a breakdown of the pricing for each of the two dashboards between the initial two months (development) and the next ten months (maintenance)?

Definitely! Here’s the model for the breakdown. Some addition points to note:

  • Roughly 60-70% of the cost is development and the remaining 30-40% is ongoing maintenance (NOTE: my earlier model incorrectly assumed a lower maintenance amount but since we’re also taking ad-hoc requests from the Celo team and community, the updated breakdown reflects these adhoc requests in addition to general product improvement work we do over time)

  • We price based on a combination of:

    • How much engineering time it costs to build and maintain the dashboards. We are an elite team of engineers from Coinbase, Amazon, Google, and Microsoft and our pricing reflects our quality and commitment to enterprise-grade support every day of the year.
    • We are a small but dedicated team and the pricing has to make economic sense for us as we have a lot of demand from other Foundations and Protocols!

If pricing is a concern, we are always open to feedback and discussion as we want to be supportive long-term partners! Making sure the Celo ecosystem feels like they are getting a great value is extremely important to us.

1 Like

Important Reminder: :mag:Transparency for Proposals

When submitting a proposal asking for funds from the Celo Community Fund, it’s crucial to disclose the address of the receiver multisign :closed_lock_with_key: and all addresses involved, along with the individuals behind each address (nickname or real name).

Additionally, each individual associated with these addresses should confirm their wallet address in a comment from their personal forum account. This is a requirement from the Governance Approvers, so let’s ensure we meet their standards for transparency.

Your cooperation is greatly appreciated. :raised_hands:

Sounds good, thanks!

1 Like

Hi @andromedae88, I wasn’t able to join the Governance call last week, but I reviewed the meeting transcript.

It’s clear to me that the Artemis dashboard provides high-quality data useful for the Celo ecosystem. My main concern is the price.

  1. Given the (macro) economic conditions, the requested budget is significant. While you provide a lot of value, and the ~ equivalent of 2-3 full-time employees makes sense, the created impact from the dashboard needs to be huge to justify issuing a budget like this.

  2. These dashboards increase in value when we have reliable and comparable data from other/comparable ecosystems to understand our numbers relative to the Beta better. I believe that in the future (especially when Interop goes live in Q1), the Superchain as a whole may want to strike a deal with Artemis, as it’s likely more efficient for both sides to create and maintain this dashboard at scale.

I suggest reducing the scope of this agreement to 9 months (Aug 1st,2024 - May 1st, 2025), 75% of the original, and reducing the direct ask to ~165K cUSD (60%).

I would love to support deepening the Artemis <> Superchain potential. I saw you missed RetroPGF3 rewards due to missing the Ballot numbers. While that may leave you with a sour taste, groups like L2 Beat and DefiLlama, have been earning six figures in additional revenue through such programs, and I think you could too in the future.

Hope the proposed scope is do-able for your team.

2 Likes

Hi @LuukDAO, thanks for the honest feedback. Let me discuss with our team and get back to you!

1 Like

Verifying my address: 0xd1a06a4477b9E4633E6E56D8f9EB9ccD39cE36Bc

1 Like

Hi all,

Thank you so much for all your comments so far. Writing out the questions that were raised in the governance call here for clarity and posterity:

Difference between Artemis and GrowThePie?

GrowThePie is great for quickly viewing analytics on L2s but institutional investors don’t want to just look at L2s but want a more holistic product to cross-compare L1s and L2s. Artemis tracks dapp activity for both L1s and L2s as well stablecoin activity for 9 chains. GrowThePie isn’t as deep in both dapp activity as well as stablecoin activity. In addition, Artemis is going to publish one of the largest stablecoin reports in the industry in Sept with Nic Carter and Visa that will be read by institutional investors across the world. Finally, we also host a quarterly dinner for all the top institutional investors. We are just far more embedded in the workflows and lives of institutional investors as an institution-focused product.

Will the Celo Activity Monitor be added to here - Artemis Dashboard?

Yes

Will cost to maintain next year be lower since upfront cost has been paid?

It depends on what Celo Foundation and the Celo community’s asks and requirements are for next year. We’ll work with the Celo community to ensure that the pricing is acceptable and fair and that the Celo community feels like the product is worth it!

Difference between the existing Celo stablecoin on Artemis’ site vs Stabila dashboard in the proposal?

The existing Celo stablecoin dashboard (Artemis Dashboard) provides stablecoin activity at a high level that’s crucial for investors but does not answer questions like how individual Celo stable-pools on Uniswap are changing (e.g., is there more liquidity?) over time as well as track the ROI for the Stabila incentives (e.g., how much TVL does $1 of incentives bring?). The Stabila dashboards will help answer these more specific questions.

Will the Stabila dashboard be private?

The Celo Foundation requested to keep the dashboard private for now but Artemis is happy to make it open if Celo Foundation is okay with it.

Would it cost more to maintain the L2 when rolls out?

It depends on how the L2 is implemented–we will work with Celo Foundation and the Celo Community to minimize disruption and changes in pricing. We want to make sure the Celo community benefits as much as possible and that we’re long-term partners!

Should the Stabila dashboard be funded out of the Stabila fund?

TBD

Example of institutional investors using Artemis to make investment decisions

Here is a list of liquid token funds and asset managers citing Artemis in their research:

In addition, we have liquid token funds interested in investing in Celo but were not able to find the data they want because there is no Celo Activity Monitor. E.g., Cody is an analyst at Spartan Group, a liquid token fund out of Singapore, who was interested in Celo:
Screenshot 2024-08-06 at 3.49.46 PM

Finally, many Celo Foundation, Mento members, and KOLs in the stablecoin space continue to rely on Artemis every day. E.g.:

  • From a couple of days ago from Rene Reinsberg: x.com
  • Mento and Markus relies on our stablecoin dashboard to track various non-USD Celo stables: x.com
  • Circle/USDC Founder and CEO just retweeted our dashboard: x.com
2 Likes

Multisigs for proposal:

Safe Wallet Address: 0xd1a06a4477b9E4633E6E56D8f9EB9ccD39cE36Bc

  • Anthony Yim (CTO) 0x9F02cb2C5Ae4CAA945fB581E8136c64eb95e89f2
  • Jon Ma (CEO) 0x4ccAe83218d7824160C76964B239F1a89373d251
  • Jimmy Zheng (COO) 0x72c131C57a994b24F171F1c208bCB111832Bea76

UPDATE Aug 7, 2024: updated to have multisig with 3 signers (need 2 to make changes)

Verifying my address: celo:0x4ccAe83218d7824160C76964B239F1a89373d251

1 Like

FYI Minimum recomended setup should be 2/3 Multisign to avoid any future issues with any lose of private key from one of the signers.

3 Likes

@0xj4an-work – sounds good. Will update.

1 Like

Verifying my address!

celo:0x72c131C57a994b24F171F1c208bCB111832Bea76

2 Likes

Thank you everyone for valuable feedback and discussion on this proposal. I’d like to chime in and offer some insights about the work Artemis has done and provide some context as the community discusses this proposal.

  1. Artemis has been a great partner to the Foundation. They have been working closely with the Celo Foundation team to scope out data requirements for the broader ecosystem. In our experience with the team, they are providing not only high quality data about Celo but also comms support, and greater visibility for project founders in our ecosystem. Approval of this proposal would make these additional dashboards and services available to the wider community and founders building on Celo enabling access to protocol level data.

  2. High quality data about transactions is crucial to the community. We at the Foundation think of data as a north star in working together to support products that have real world use cases and adoption. And we view these dashboards as a public good for the community since they can be used by everyone to work towards the collective mission of Celo being the ecosystem for real world use cases.

  3. The Superchain ecosystem may require dashboards in the future, but it is difficult to predict their scope and data requirements at this point. For the moment specific functionalities need to be built out that are aligned to Celo specific growth priorities.

It’s encouraging to see the thoughtful discussion in the community and hope that this additional context is helpful in evaluating the proposal.

5 Likes

Thank you for all the comments and questions on this proposal so far everyone!

Exciting news, we also just added cKES to our stablecoin dashboard today: Artemis Dashboard

We know that’s an ask from Markus @ Mento!

2 Likes

Also verifying my address: 0x9F02cb2C5Ae4CAA945fB581E8136c64eb95e89f2

1 Like

Hi @LuukDAO – thanks again for the feedback!

We discussed as a team and decided to use the average last 45 day CELO price to derive the amount of CELO we’re requesting. This comes out to ~509k CELO (US$239k), which is a ~13% discount. See exact calculation here.

We think this helps make the price more equitable as it takes into account the volatility of the market and ensures that we can continue providing high-quality data and support to the Celo ecosystem. We understand the current economic pressures and the importance of ensuring funds are used efficiently. By aligning our request with the recent average CELO price, we hope to balance the needs of the Celo community with our ability to deliver the impactful results you’re looking for.

We are committed to the success of the Celo ecosystem and are open to discussions on how we can further optimize this partnership. Looking forward to hearing your thoughts!

3 Likes

Thanks for iterating on this proposal and the budget, @andromedae88

One of the priorities I see (given that CELO is valued at a low point) is reducing potential sales pressure.

Could you estimate which share of the requested CELO you would imagine liquidating in the next 12 months? Or is this a long-term holding for Artemins?

I see value in having the share you would sell to pay for costs paid out in cUSD instead of CELO.

Thanks for iterating on this proposal and the budget, @andromedae88

One of the priorities I see (given that CELO is valued at a low point) is reducing potential sales pressure.

Could you estimate which share of the requested CELO you would imagine liquidating in the next 12 months? Or is this a long-term holding for Artemins?

I see value in having the share you would sell to pay for costs paid out in cUSD instead of CELO.

Hey @LuukDAO – that’s a great question. We don’t have a specific plan right now. Happy to explore something that reduces sell pressure on CELO as that’s a valid concern.

We mainly need USD to cover operating expenses since our biggest costs are running our massive data pipeline that ingests data for 30+ chains and salary.